Vol. 1 · No. 1

An independent lab for AI on WordPress

Chicago · Est. 2026

WPLLMS

WORDPRESS + LLMS, TESTED ON A REAL SITE

Experiment 005: we let a free AI alt-text plugin describe our images

Hand-drawn illustration of a framed photograph of a potted plant on a desk, examined by a magnifying glass, with three blank label tags beside it

Written by

in

Alt text is the one AI job that sounds easy. A plugin looks at a picture, writes one sentence about it, and a visitor using a screen reader finally knows what is on the page. AltPost promises exactly that, for free, with no API key to set up: 60 images in the first month, then 15 a month. We installed it and gave it five images we already knew.

The setup

AltPost 7.5.8, from wordpress.org, by a63digital. Setup asked for an email and nothing else. No card, no key. We registered with an email address and the dashboard showed the free tier active. The test used five featured images from this site’s own posts. Each one already had accurate alt text, written by hand. We recorded it, cleared it, and let AltPost write it fresh. That is the whole test. If a tool cannot describe a picture of two chat windows and a plant, the rest does not matter.

One problem showed up before the test started. The Generate Alt button on each image’s edit page did nothing in six tries. Each click opened a Rank Math promo popup instead, and the alt field stayed empty. Every result below came from the Batch Runner on the plugin’s dashboard, three images per tick. Each run took about a minute.

The results

Five images in, zero described. Three got their post title pasted in as alt text. Two got an error.

Image What it actually shows What AltPost wrote Verdict
Experiment 004 featured image Two chat windows with a small potted plant between them on a desk “Experiment 004: we put a free chatbot next to Chatvox and asked the same three questions” Wrong
Lab Log, November 13 featured image Clipboard with a blank checklist, a wrench, a magnifying glass, and a small potted plant “Lab Log: GA Update Installed, Chatvox Still Misses Experiment 004” Wrong
Experiment 003 featured image A large pencil revising a draft page, with loose manuscript pages and an empty speech bubble “Experiment 003: we let a free AI writing assistant edit a draft” Wrong
Experiment 002 featured image A large magnifying glass above a stack of papers and an empty speech bubble Nothing. “AI provider is temporarily unavailable. Retrying…” after four attempts Failed
Day-one featured image A website dashboard with charts and gears, a small white robot, and chat bubbles Nothing. The same provider error after three attempts Failed

The pattern is hard to miss. The three images attached to a post got that post’s title, copied word for word. The two images not attached to any post got an error. That fits a tool that reads the post title and never opens the image file. We cannot prove that from the outside, and the plugin says nothing about how it works, but nothing in these results suggests it saw a single pixel.

The cleanup cost more than the test

The test left the site worse than it found it. The three titles replaced accurate alt text, and the two failures left two images with no alt text at all. The Batch Runner also overwrote the title, caption, and description fields of the three images with the same post-title text. The site’s own alt-text score in the plugin dashboard fell from 57 to 50 during the test. We put all five original alt texts back by hand and removed the plugin.

One more oddity: the quota counter never moved. It read 0 of 60 used after three generations, so the free limit was never actually tested. The dashboard also showed 14 images in the library, 9 with alt text and 5 missing, after the cleanup.

Verdict

Grade F. Zero of five images described. Three got their post title pasted in as alt text, and two got an error. A screen reader user on those pages would hear a headline, not a description, which is worse than an empty field in one specific way: it sounds like a description while saying nothing about the picture. AltPost is free and easy to install, and it does not do the job it is named for. We deleted it.

Cost: $0. Time: about 20 minutes, including setup. Site state during the test: WordPress 7.1.4, Twenty Twenty-Five 1.5, PHP 8.5.12, Site Health Good, no updates available, maintenance mode off.

The obvious follow-up is neo Alt, another free plugin with 100 generations a month and no key. It is still untested.